Rec
📔
I realised one of my main shortcomings in my musicmaking hobby is feeling confidence in structuring songs in the broadest sense. so I’ve started a book where I analyse the structural elements of songs that I find appealing.
my knowledge of theory is quite limited, and I will keep it this way because ngl it’s boring and I enjoy music as a more intuitive practice. However I am really learning a lot from this and I hope doing it will allow me to develop a personal vernacular of song structure letting me fully realise my musical ideas
recommendation image
Feb 23, 2025

Comments (3)

Make an account to reply.
image
this is amazing! i also have limited knowledge on music theory (and agree with you about keeping the process more intuitive than strictly academic) & find myself creating playlists based on specific production elements that i gravitate towards/want to incorporate into my own music & deconstruct. i’m very much a visual learner and this is such a great way to get a better idea of what makes music you enjoy sound the way it sounds. ty for sharing! 😊
Feb 23, 2025
3
image
Studying outside of a traditional academic environment is such a great practice 🤌
Feb 23, 2025
3
image
this is a such a great idea! I’ve been wanting to really focus on developing my writing and find ways to study great literature in a more pertinent and personal way, so I might try doing something like this so all my thoughts and references live in a single place. This a wonderful!
Feb 23, 2025
3

Related Recs

Rec
recommendation image
📝
I've been writing/playing/recording/releasing my own music since around 2016. Music's been one of my passions in life since I was 10, all I wanted to do was write songs and play them. I had this purple notebook throughout middle school that I would write song ideas down in, mostly lyrics that I had a tune in mind for. But as with a lot of things in my life, I felt insecure and lacked confidence in my abilities and that led me to pursue the visual arts, which is a passion I'd had since I can remember and I got a lot of praise in growing up.
I've been trying to make music for the sake of making it and not for the pipe dream of making a living off of it. To me, doing things like art and music for money is a will killer; it strips all the passion and creativity from the work and it becomes solely about money. It would be nice if some day I luck into making enough money to support myself via my art, but I don't think that's going to happen and I'm not going to play the systems available to me and sell my soul in the process. Going to art school was a bad idea. Anyway, I have been daydreaming here and there about making some instrumental work and making a portfolio, try to get composer work maybe. Don't think my style lends itself to that but you never know. It's less personal that way too, with no words.
The words are the hardest part. I don't know what to say, don't know what I should put my voice behind. I want to be honest about myself, my life, my experience since that's the only thing I would call myself an expert on. And I've been trying to build that up like a muscle, trying to get myself comfortable with writing and singing what I've written. Singing in general. Trying to improve my playing too. I'm not sure if I'll ever get to a point where I'd be playing in front of an audience night after night, that's not really something I want. I believe in the power of performance, something I've been wanting production wise is to keep it simple. Vocals and me playing whatever instrument at the same time, a live recording. I think having to perform the same song every day kills that.
I've been listening to a lot of different music to learn from it, appreciate it. This started with the blues and folk, and where the name Sam the Wayfarer comes from. A lot of folk and blues musicians have names like that- First name the something. Rambling first name, Blind first name, etc. I'm going to switch to a different name, more of a band name than my first name being involved. Not willing to do my first and last name. Not sure if I should make it its own project or just put it over top the wayfarer stuff. But it'll be more of the same.
I don't have a big sound and I like to experiment, play around, do what comes naturally. I'd love to make louder music, but I don't have the space to scream and yell and thrash just yet. I just want to be me.
Jul 10, 2024
Rec
➡️
from my own work, I’ve always thought about album structure in terms of a narrative arc. first, I think about what the overall message of the project is. what’s the main idea or thesis? next I think about what each song has to say and how it relates to the overall theme. maybe the songs towards the beginning have more tension with the main idea and the ones toward the end resolve that, maybe the last song is a final affirmation of the main idea.
I also think good album structure is served by dynamics. having a bunch of songs all together with a similar tone/energy level/style makes things feel stagnant. having consecutive tracks contrast helps to keep the listener’s attention and makes the album feel like more of a journey.
the biggest thing, though, is to keep the listener engaged for as much of the album as possible. if you listen through the full project yourself and feel your attention waning, your mind wandering, or just bored, maybe there’s a different track order that could help with that. it’s difficult to do with your own work, but if you can listen with a slightly detached perspective then you can gauge whether the listening experience would be compelling to your audience.
Feb 28, 2025
Rec
recommendation image
🎹
I’m taking music seriously in 2025 and trying to learn how to write songs. I feel like I’m behind the crowd as I’m starting in my 20s and know very little actual music theory. But I just WANT TO. So I guess im gonna.
Wish me LUCK xoxo
Dec 25, 2024

Top Recs from @st9n

Rec
📻
get da NTS app or whatever radio station u fuck with and just put that on in the morning. ya your brain might want stimulation before u can get out of bed but it doesn’t need instagram reels level shit. Just some fresh music is sometimes all u need
Feb 20, 2025
Rec
recommendation image
🚫
informational riches, so close yet out of reach
Jan 20, 2025
Rec
✍️
separate your to do list into what does and doesn’t require a screen, and do those lists separately
means you aren’t constantly bouncing between a screen and the material world. Bonus points if your screenless list is completed without any music or podcasts or anything at all. You’re hiding your true power level by blocking all your thinking with consumption!!
posting a neoluddite rec on pifyi is basically reaction farming I’ve realised but I’m NOT that cynical I promise
Jan 15, 2025