it gives a softer look than liquid liner - i have it in brown. when you first put it on you can smudge/soften it, i usually use my finger or an angled brush depending on the look i want, and then it dries pretty quickly and lasts a long time. plus huda beauty has been very vocal in supporting palestine which is cool! 🍉
and i also like the elf expert liquid liner in jet black if i want something sharper (which was already rec’d here but i’m seconding). it’s not smudge-able. the elf liner is a lot cheaper price-wise
(also both brands are cruelty free yay 🐰💞 !!)