🍪
for enjoyers of chewy Chips Ahoy! cookies and Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind (2004) and anyone looking for remote work snacks --- my dad and i have been snacking on these whenever we get the chance
i recently went on a trip to PA with some family and we visited the Pepperidge Farm Company Store! my cousin and i collapsed when we saw these Montauk cookies because we just rewatched the movie together
didn't realize how many kinds of cookies Pepperidge Farm is responsible for until i got there.
only familiar with their Milano cookies, i was ecstatic to see that they have different cookies under the names of different cities (i.e. Tahoe, Nantucket, Brussels, Verona)!! i'm guessingg each cookie matches the vibe of each city. soo if anyone from Montauk could let me know if their city is truly like a soft-baked milk chocolate cookie, that would be cool!
i don't remember the last time i browsed the cookie aisle in my local market but i swear i have never seen this array of Pepperidge Farm city cookies... i guess it is my next mission to go and check
What Pepperidge Farm city cookie are you?
Feb 12, 2025
Comments (1)
Make an account to reply.
woww these were a mainstay in my childhood home and I had completely forgotten!! ty for this fluffy and just sweet enough memory
Related Recs
A friend and I got two chocolate chip cookies from different places in Brooklyn Heights yesterday (that tiktok croissant place and Ella Crown). It was cool to go bite for bite and seriously evaluate what I like in a cookie. Also very interesting to realize that my front runner at the beginning (the large boi) was not my top choice for the last bite. Interested to do this with other food types going forward!
Also not apologizing for that sexy grease stain (from the l’appartement tahini one).
Mar 11, 2024
thousands of 5⭐️ Reviews for a reasons
Warm up and eat w pistachio ice cream, chewy nutty savory sweet makes me NUT
Apr 29, 2024
An affordable indulgence… some say the place has gone down hill, but these cookies keep me coming back.
*order as soon as you sit down since they are baked to order and take 10 minutes
Dec 30, 2024
Top Recs from @pickledluya
pick a number from 12 - 466 and i will tell u what bird u are !!!
i got this huge book from the library weeks ago and will be returning it late tomorrow </3
Mar 12, 2025
with white rice and veggies
and ask for extra chicken it's worth the extra cost
soo delicious and so nostalgic for me!
i used to split one with my sister every time we went to the mall as kids except we would get no veggies
Feb 13, 2025